You had me until the title. That being said...
This guy isn't relevant in any way so I wouldn't worry too much about what he says. He is right, however, about both the community and the gear. GMs on the other 2 highest voted sites are childish and arrogant. I'm not going to get into the rest of them. The players are all wannabe-factor types who, to be quite honest, weren't s*** on official and think that's going to be any different here. The gear can be ridiculous. Anyone who played Blue Dragon back in its "prime" saw that. Plus the constant QQ about autoclicking by people who were too dumb to realize what instacast meant... Long story short, private servers are a dying industry. Official isn't much better off either, though, so I guess we shouldn't feel bad.