Until dawn
None of em really scared me i've played: Evil WithinOutlastAmnesiaDoom 3 (if you wanna count that as a scary movie)The Grudge (kinda boring but it does have jumpscares)Silent HillI'd give Until Dawn first place tbh,cool story and loved the cutscenes.
OutlastPenumbraAmnesia(still playing this, custom stories are scarier than the original story) Slender the arrivalFive nights at Freddy's
Which version of 5 Nights at freddy's did you play?
old Nintendo Mario game! it was really scary
Until Dawn wasn't that scary until the very end of them w.e things are that literally wanted to kill everyone.
Silent HillLayers of FearOutlast Resident Evil 1 (remake on gamecube)
Watch this on a full screen.
Evil Within.