Epic Perfect World

+40 Physical Attack or +10 Strength?

Offline ๖ۣۜĐomgrath

  • Nightmare Berserker
  • www.youtube.com/domgrathpw Guides, Gameplay, Livestreams (Amy's property don't mad)
  • Characters: Đomgrath Nemesis Sauron
  • Faction: Artifex
Mathematically speaking.

It's rumored that +100 Attack (Drakeflame Stone) will give more Physical Attack than it's +20 Strength counterpart. 

I remember on Storm people would go for the +40 stats instead of +STR as well for Physical APS DD classes.

Now; thinking about engravings. Would a +2 Attack, +40 P Attack ornament give more Physical Attack than a +2 Attack, +10 Strength?

I know many prefer the +dex/+str adds because of the PDEF/CRIT bonus's given, however I'd like to know mathematically which is better for raw damage

Offline Savi

  • Member
  • ♥Zhoephast was here♥!ace too♥
Physical attack better for raw damage.

Edit: now, I tested through pw calc and I think str better. Need someone to test ing.
Last Edit: Mar 21, 2016, 08:20 am by Savi

Offline AuH.s.n

  • avatar
  • SnE
  • 80% of success is showing up.
go ingame and do a simple restat and check it.
as for wizard, each magic adds 18 magic attack.
so 10magic= 180 magic attack.
Just DotA, For Ever, Till The End
I'm Not that Good
Maybe am in F*cking, But not at evrything!
زندگیمو میسازم، اونطوری که میخواهم

Offline Nea

  • Game Master
  • M♥
  • Flowered profile hi
  • Characters: Nea EA Camp
Go game
Use full new set of cards with old durability card lorelei
Remove weap
Test on some1
Now replace lorelei with the new s card (64phy attack loss)
See difference
Now put lorelei back and replace 1 card that has 10str (S+) with a normal s card with same atk lvl but no str
U will notice dmg difference
And calculate each str point how much it dropped
And how much dmg did 64phy att drop
This way u can calculate each phy attack vs each str point
Ex: 10str less from 500dmg u hit x
500-x= y
Y= 10str
64 phy attk , from 500 to z
500-z=q
Q/64 = p( dmg of 1phy att)
Now 40x P= a number representing what u gonna compare to str in order to see
Correct me if im wrong
Helpdesk         GameGuides             Rules             UserPanel

Offline Balnazar

  • Godfather of Worms
  • I be back m8
  • Characters: Balnazar
  • Faction: Worms
Go game
Use full new set of cards with old durability card lorelei
Remove weap
Test on some1
Now replace lorelei with the new s card (64phy attack loss)
See difference
Now put lorelei back and replace 1 card that has 10str (S+) with a normal s card with same atk lvl but no str
U will notice dmg difference
And calculate each str point how much it dropped
And how much dmg did 64phy att drop
This way u can calculate each phy attack vs each str point
Ex: 10str less from 500dmg u hit x
500-x= y
Y= 10str
64 phy attk , from 500 to z
500-z=q
Q/64 = p( dmg of 1phy att)
Now 40x P= a number representing what u gonna compare to str in order to see
Correct me if im wrong
dayum *claps*  :police:
Agatio, EvilTouch, Alexypk, Magestic, Chocolate, Dream and Suns were all slain by Balnazar. Keeping scores?

Offline ๖ۣۜĐomgrath

  • Nightmare Berserker
  • www.youtube.com/domgrathpw Guides, Gameplay, Livestreams (Amy's property don't mad)
  • Characters: Đomgrath Nemesis Sauron
  • Faction: Artifex
Do you honestly think I'm going to be testing elaborate mathematical hypothesis? 

I need a flat answer. 

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

I'm asking because I literally only want to maximize my damage output; and I rolled a +2 Attack, +40 Belt. 

If +2,+40 is < +2,+10

That's all I need to know

Offline Arrow

  • Oliver Queen
  • First they laugh then they copy.
  • Characters: Arrow
I need a flat answer.

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

Yes, it would give higher phy atk then 10 str point.

Offline BAQWULF

  • Best barb on server
  • I can tell if you are fail or not just by looking at your gear...
  • Characters: BAQWULF
  • Faction: ArtOFwar
your dmg will still suck cause too much dex :normal-3:
The moment when haters become fans *rofl*



Offline Kinsei

  • Forum Veteran
  • Characters: Kinsei
  • Faction: Team69
Physical attack better for dmg
I kneel only to God, and I don't see him here

Offline Mentalista

  • avatar
  • Forum Veteran
  • Faction: Tyrants
On psy +64 mag atk = 10 mag. What means each mag point = +6,4 mag atk

And +10 mag or +64 mag atk = ~800 more magic atk on the C menu.

If the same logic applys on phy classes, then 10 str is better than 40 phy atk.

Last Edit: Mar 21, 2016, 02:18 pm by Mentalista


My damage log collection NEW

Offline Nea

  • Game Master
  • M♥
  • Flowered profile hi
  • Characters: Nea EA Camp
Do you honestly think I'm going to be testing elaborate mathematical hypothesis?

I need a flat answer.

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

I'm asking because I literally only want to maximize my damage output; and I rolled a +2 Attack, +40 Belt.

If +2,+40 is < +2,+10

That's all I need to know
My calculations just answer it
Since u just have diff of phy attk between 40phy attk and 10str
Just do it in game its not more than 6th grade maths
Helpdesk         GameGuides             Rules             UserPanel

Offline Swane

  • avatar
  • Creator of Elf Archer
  • Characters: Almighty
  • Faction: Apollumi Master
Don't know about melee classes but +10 dex gives more phy att than +40 phy att (tested on EA with full DPH gear)
Helpdesk         Guides             Rules             User Panel
Let X = total damage from gears + cards + meridians ;
And Y = total multiplier from strength + mastery ; 
Then 10 strengths > 40 physical attack when:
X > 600*Y

P.S ceteris paribus 


Offline C

  • Inactive.

Just do it in game its not more than 6th grade maths

Hard to do math when someone doesn't even know what 60+ 63 is....

Offline Salt Lord

  • You're so mad at a game.
  • Who are you and why do you seem to have some weird obsession with mentioning me in EPW comments?
  • Characters: リサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420
  • Faction: Teach Me Barb Please
wswsw
ripwwswswsws
↓↓↓↓↓

421242sdasddsaf]\][\]
http://tiny.cc/xXxWreckinEasiesxXx[/size
465435ewffdsq\\\1342