Epic Perfect World

+40 Physical Attack or +10 Strength?

Offline ๖ۣۜĐomgrath

  • Nightmare Berserker
  • www.youtube.com/domgrathpw Guides, Gameplay, Livestreams (Amy's property don't mad)
  • Characters: Đomgrath Nemesis Sauron
  • Faction: Artifex
Mathematically speaking.

It's rumored that +100 Attack (Drakeflame Stone) will give more Physical Attack than it's +20 Strength counterpart. 

I remember on Storm people would go for the +40 stats instead of +STR as well for Physical APS DD classes.

Now; thinking about engravings. Would a +2 Attack, +40 P Attack ornament give more Physical Attack than a +2 Attack, +10 Strength?

I know many prefer the +dex/+str adds because of the PDEF/CRIT bonus's given, however I'd like to know mathematically which is better for raw damage

Offline Savi

  • Member
  • ♥Zhoephast was here♥!ace too♥
Physical attack better for raw damage.

Edit: now, I tested through pw calc and I think str better. Need someone to test ing.
Last Edit: Mar 21, 2016, 08:20 am by Savi

Offline AuH.s.n

  • avatar
  • SnE
  • 80% of success is showing up.
go ingame and do a simple restat and check it.
as for wizard, each magic adds 18 magic attack.
so 10magic= 180 magic attack.
Just DotA, For Ever, Till The End
I'm Not that Good
Maybe am in F*cking, But not at evrything!
زندگیمو میسازم، اونطوری که میخواهم

Online Seby

  • Support Member
  • M♥
  • Characters: Chaos Veracity
Go game
Use full new set of cards with old durability card lorelei
Remove weap
Test on some1
Now replace lorelei with the new s card (64phy attack loss)
See difference
Now put lorelei back and replace 1 card that has 10str (S+) with a normal s card with same atk lvl but no str
U will notice dmg difference
And calculate each str point how much it dropped
And how much dmg did 64phy att drop
This way u can calculate each phy attack vs each str point
Ex: 10str less from 500dmg u hit x
500-x= y
Y= 10str
64 phy attk , from 500 to z
500-z=q
Q/64 = p( dmg of 1phy att)
Now 40x P= a number representing what u gonna compare to str in order to see
Correct me if im wrong
Signature by Royal
Helpdesk         GameGuides             Rules             UserPanel

Offline Balnazar

  • Godfather of Worms
  • I be back m8
  • Characters: Balnazar
  • Faction: Worms
Go game
Use full new set of cards with old durability card lorelei
Remove weap
Test on some1
Now replace lorelei with the new s card (64phy attack loss)
See difference
Now put lorelei back and replace 1 card that has 10str (S+) with a normal s card with same atk lvl but no str
U will notice dmg difference
And calculate each str point how much it dropped
And how much dmg did 64phy att drop
This way u can calculate each phy attack vs each str point
Ex: 10str less from 500dmg u hit x
500-x= y
Y= 10str
64 phy attk , from 500 to z
500-z=q
Q/64 = p( dmg of 1phy att)
Now 40x P= a number representing what u gonna compare to str in order to see
Correct me if im wrong
dayum *claps*  :police:
Agatio, EvilTouch, Alexypk, Magestic, Chocolate, Dream and Suns were all slain by Balnazar. Keeping scores?

Offline ๖ۣۜĐomgrath

  • Nightmare Berserker
  • www.youtube.com/domgrathpw Guides, Gameplay, Livestreams (Amy's property don't mad)
  • Characters: Đomgrath Nemesis Sauron
  • Faction: Artifex
Do you honestly think I'm going to be testing elaborate mathematical hypothesis? 

I need a flat answer. 

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

I'm asking because I literally only want to maximize my damage output; and I rolled a +2 Attack, +40 Belt. 

If +2,+40 is < +2,+10

That's all I need to know

Offline Arrow

  • Oliver Queen
  • First they laugh then they copy.
  • Characters: Arrow
I need a flat answer.

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

Yes, it would give higher phy atk then 10 str point.

Offline BAQWULF

  • Best barb on server
  • I can tell if you are fail or not just by looking at your gear...
  • Characters: BAQWULF
  • Faction: ArtOFwar
your dmg will still suck cause too much dex :normal-3:
The moment when haters become fans *rofl*



Offline Kinsei

  • Forum Veteran
  • Characters: Kinsei
  • Faction: Team69
Physical attack better for dmg
I kneel only to God, and I don't see hime here

Offline Mentalista

  • avatar
  • Forum Veteran
  • Faction: Tyrants
On psy +64 mag atk = 10 mag. What means each mag point = +6,4 mag atk

And +10 mag or +64 mag atk = ~800 more magic atk on the C menu.

If the same logic applys on phy classes, then 10 str is better than 40 phy atk.

Last Edit: Mar 21, 2016, 02:18 pm by Mentalista


My damage log collection NEW

Online Seby

  • Support Member
  • M♥
  • Characters: Chaos Veracity
Do you honestly think I'm going to be testing elaborate mathematical hypothesis?

I need a flat answer.

Would +40 PATTK be better than +10 STR for a BARBARIAN (in terms of raw damage, including nothing else)

I'm asking because I literally only want to maximize my damage output; and I rolled a +2 Attack, +40 Belt.

If +2,+40 is < +2,+10

That's all I need to know
My calculations just answer it
Since u just have diff of phy attk between 40phy attk and 10str
Just do it in game its not more than 6th grade maths
Signature by Royal
Helpdesk         GameGuides             Rules             UserPanel

Offline Swane

  • avatar
  • Creator of Elf Archer
  • Characters: Almighty
  • Faction: Apollumi Master
Don't know about melee classes but +10 dex gives more phy att than +40 phy att (tested on EA with full DPH gear)
Let X = total damage from gears + cards + meridians ;
And Y = total multiplier from strength + mastery ; 
Then 10 strengths > 40 physical attack when:
X > 600*Y

P.S ceteris paribus 


Offline C

  • Candy Cane
  • Characters: 𝓒𝓪𝓷𝓭𝔂 | 𝓒𝓱𝓻𝓲𝓼𝓽𝓲
  • Faction: 𝓢𝓲𝓮𝓰𝓮

Just do it in game its not more than 6th grade maths

Hard to do math when someone doesn't even know what 60+ 63 is....

𝓐𝓵𝓵 𝓽𝓱𝓪𝓽 𝓰𝓵𝓲𝓽𝓽𝓮𝓻𝓼 𝓲𝓼 𝓷𝓸𝓽 𝓰𝓸𝓵𝓭. 

Offline Salt Lord

  • You're so mad at a game.
  • Who are you and why do you seem to have some weird obsession with mentioning me in EPW comments?
  • Characters: リサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420 / 現代のコンピューリサフランク420
  • Faction: Teach Me Barb Please
wswsw
ripwwswswsws
↓↓↓↓↓

421242sdasddsaf]\][\]
http://tiny.cc/xXxWreckinEasiesxXx[/size
465435ewffdsq\\\1342