This is really, really gay
I dare you to play the Midnight Man. Based on a Pagan ritual for punishing those that went against beliefs or those that were in charge. As such, having anything referring to organized religion may work against you, but if you feel more comfortable wearing such amulets, that's up to you. Know this, though, The Midnight Man is more of a thought form than an actual non-corporeal being, as such, the Midnight Man knows your fears because you were the one that summoned him.
The way to play The Midnight Man below. Personally, I don't suggest playing it, but you seem like the strong willed type, so I'm not too worried.
http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Midnight_Game