I personally feel that BM's are fine the way they are, It's the Barbs that need help. in a 1v1 the only way for us to beat anyone with a charm (every one on the server) is to use aps. sure we hit hard as hell with axes but we are to slow to beat the charm. about the only way to win a 1v1 is to use aps/claws which leaves us screwed as far as phys def (ie. tiger form) and we have no useable skills.